Saturday, June 15, 2024

ADVERTISING: Advertorial — Navigating the world of wine ratings: A guide for the discerning oenophile

by LAURA OLSON/The Dinner Party
| May 22, 2024 1:00 AM

In the vast and intricate world of wine, ratings have become an indispensable tool for enthusiasts and collectors alike, providing a roadmap to navigate the sea of choices that grace our shelves and cellars. However, the art of interpreting these numerical scores can be a nuanced endeavor, one that requires an understanding of the history, scales, and personalities behind the ratings.

The practice of rating wines can be traced back to the late 19th century, when early wine critics and writers began assigning numerical values to the bottles they tasted. This primitive system laid the groundwork for the more formalized rating structures that would emerge in the latter half of the 20th century, as the wine industry experienced a renaissance and the demand for critical evaluation grew.

Today, the most widely recognized rating system is the 100-point scale, popularized by influential critics like Robert Parker Jr. and the Wine Spectator magazine. This scale assigns a score ranging from 50 to 100, with wines earning scores in the 90s considered exceptional, and those in the high 90s and above regarded as truly iconic and rare.

However, it's crucial to understand that these numerical ratings are inherently subjective, reflecting the personal tastes and preferences of the critic or publication. Robert Parker, for instance, is renowned for his affinity for bold, fruit-forward, and opulent styles, while others, like Jancis Robinson, may favor more restrained and elegant expressions.

Beyond these household names, there are numerous other respected voices in the wine world, each with their own unique rating systems and stylistic leanings. Decanter, a venerable British publication, employs a panel of expert judges to assess wines, using a 100-point scale that often leans towards a more traditional, Old-World sensibility.

Vinous, founded by Antonio Galloni, has emerged as a prominent voice in recent years, with a team of critics offering detailed tasting notes and ratings on a 100-point scale. Galloni himself is known for his appreciation of balance and complexity, often favoring wines with a more understated elegance.

The International Wine Challenge (IWC) takes a collaborative approach, assembling panels of expert judges from around the world to evaluate wines through a rigorous blind tasting process. They use a unique scoring system that combines quality, value, and commercial appeal, making their ratings particularly valuable for trade buyers and sommeliers.

James Suckling, a former senior editor at Wine Spectator, has carved out a niche as a respected independent critic, offering his own 100-point ratings and tasting notes. Suckling's palate tends to gravitate towards ripe, opulent styles, often awarding high scores to bold, fruit-forward wines.

Jeb Dunnuck, another former Wine Advocate critic, has built a reputation for his discerning palate and a rating system that emphasizes balance, depth, and age-worthiness. Dunnuck's scores, which also use a 100-point scale, often align with those seeking wines with a more classical, restrained profile.

Jancis Robinson, one of the most respected and influential voices in the world of wine, takes a more holistic approach to her evaluations. While she employs a 20-point scale, her tasting notes and commentary offer invaluable insights into a wine's character, terroir, and overall quality, often favoring wines with a sense of place and restraint.

When interpreting wine ratings, it's essential to familiarize yourself with the preferences and biases of the critic or organization in question. A wine that receives a 95-point score from one critic may not necessarily align with your personal palate, while a more modest rating from a critic whose tastes mirror your own could be a better indication of a wine's potential to delight.

Moreover, it's important to recognize that ratings are merely a snapshot in time, capturing the wine's expression at a specific moment in its evolution. As wines age and develop, their characteristics can shift, potentially altering their perceived quality and score.

In the end, the true art of appreciating wine lies not in blindly following ratings, but in developing your own understanding and preferences. Use ratings as a guide, but don't be afraid to explore and form your own opinions. Attend tastings, experiment with different regions and styles, and take note of the wines that resonate most profoundly with your palate. 

Check out the Dinner Party website for a list of our upcoming tasting and pop-up wine dinners for a chance to explore wines from around the world! May 31, we taste through four of the top AVAs in Washington at our Washington Wine pop-up dinner. On June 5, we are joined by Napa’s esteemed Freemark Abbey Vineyards and Matanza’s Creek for a tasting of five delectable wines. We continue the journey on June 14 with our South Africa wines pop-up dinner and move onto Wines of Spain for our Aug. 15 pop-up dinner. Give us a call at the shop if you’d like to join!

• • •

Laura Olson is co-owner of The Dinner Party along with her partner, Joe Petersen. You can also follow us on Facebook at!/dinnerpartyshop or visit