Probating a Will vs. Trust Administration in Idaho
Robert J. Green
In Idaho, the processes of probate and trust administration serve distinct purposes in managing and distributing assets after someone passes away. While both mechanisms aim to transfer assets to beneficiaries, they differ significantly in their procedures, timeline, costs, and privacy considerations. This article explores the key differences between probate and trust administration in Idaho.
Probate Administration
Although there are some exceptions, in Idaho most estates which are controlled through a last will and testament (as opposed to a trust) will need to be submitted to probate court to be utilized. Probate is the court-supervised process of validating a deceased person's will and distributing their assets to beneficiaries. In Idaho, probate becomes necessary when a deceased person (the decedent) owned assets worth more than $100,000 in their name (rather than holding the assets in a trust), or when they owned real estate worth any amount in their name.
Key Features of Idaho Probate
The probate process in Idaho typically involves several mandatory steps such as:
1. Filing a petition with the court to open probate and appoint a personal representative
2. Notifying creditors and beneficiaries through published notices and direct mail
3. Creating an inventory of estate assets and providing it to required parties
4. Paying valid creditor claims and taxes
5. Distributing remaining assets to beneficiaries
6. Filing a final accounting with the court
7. Asking the probate judge to be released from the jurisdiction of the probate court
The time needed to complete a probate in North Idaho generally ranges from six months to two years, depending on the estate's complexity and whether any disputes arise. I tell most of my clients to assume the process will take nine to twelve months. During this time, some assets may remain frozen until the court authorizes their distribution.
Costs and Privacy Considerations
Probate expenses in North Idaho typically include:
• Court filing fees
• Attorney fees
• Personal representative fees
• Publication costs for legal notices
• Professional fees for appraisals, real estate, or accounting services
One aspect of probate that often bothers families is its public nature. All documents filed with the court become public record, potentially exposing family financial matters and beneficiary information to public scrutiny.
Trust Administration
Trust administration, by contrast, involves managing and distributing assets held within a trust according to the trust document's terms. This process occurs outside of court supervision and typically begins immediately after the death of the person who established the trust (the Trustor).
Key Features of Trust Administration
The trust administration process in Idaho generally includes:
1. Notifying beneficiaries of their interest in the trust
2. Creating an inventory of trust assets
3. Managing and investing trust assets
4. Paying debts and taxes
5. Distributing assets according to trust terms
6. Maintaining accurate records of all transactions
Depending on the terms and requirements of the trust, the age of the beneficiaries, and the nature of the assets held in trust, there are many other tasks or duties a trustee of a trust may need to attend to while administering a trust after a death.
However, unlike probate, trust administration can often be completed in three to six months, assuming no complications or disputes arise. Assets can be distributed more quickly since court approval isn't required for each step, and no one is required to attend court hearings.
Costs and Privacy Advantages
Trust administration costs typically include:
• Trustee fees
• Attorney fees (if legal assistance is needed at all — and typically there is much less for an attorney to do compared to a probated estate)
• Professional fees for appraisals, real estate, or accounting services
A trust administration typically provides a family substantially more privacy protection compared to probate. Since court supervision isn't required, trust terms and asset distributions remain private. Unlike a will during a probate, a trust document does not become a public record that anyone can obtain and read. This confidentiality can help prevent family disputes and protect beneficiaries from unwanted publicity.
Key Differences and Considerations
Several factors distinguish trust administration from probate in Idaho:
Speed of Administration:
Trust administration generally proceeds more quickly than probate since it doesn't require court oversight, appearances before a judge, or mandatory waiting periods for creditor claims.
Cost Effectiveness:
While creating a trust initially costs more than writing a will, trust administration typically proves less expensive than probate in the long run due to reduced legal fees and court costs.
Privacy Protection:
Trust administration offers significantly better privacy protection than probate, as trust documents and distributions remain confidential rather than becoming public record.
Flexibility:
Trusts offer greater flexibility in asset management and distribution, allowing for staged distributions for younger beneficiaries, special needs provisions, and other customized arrangements that might be more difficult or impossible to implement through probate.
What is Right for You?
The choice between relying on probate or trust administration in Idaho depends on various factors, including estate size, privacy concerns, and family circumstances. While probate provides court oversight that may benefit some situations, trust administration offers greater privacy, flexibility, and potential cost savings for many Idaho residents. Understanding these differences can help families make informed decisions about their estate planning strategy and better prepare for the eventual administration of their assets. Seek competent advice from a seasoned attorney to determine the best choice for your family.
My law firm is currently offering free telephonic, electronic, or in-person consultations concerning creating or reviewing estate planning documents.
• • •
Robert J. Green is an Elder Law, Trust, Estate, Probate, & Guardianship Attorney and the owner of Kootenai Law Group, PLLC in Coeur d’Alene. If you have questions about estate planning, probates, wills, trusts, powers of attorney, guardianships, Medicaid planning, or VA Benefit planning, contact Robert at 208-765-6555, Robert@KootenaiLaw.com, or visit www.KootenaiLaw.com.
This has been presented as general information and not as legal advice. Do not engage in legal decision-making without the advice of a competent attorney after discussion of your specific circumstances.