Sunday, November 22, 2026
34.0°F

OPINION: Idaho and the state of religious liberty

by BEN TOEWS / Guest Opinion
| November 22, 2026 1:00 AM

This summer, First Liberty Institute’s Center for Religion, Culture & Democracy released its 2026 Religious Liberty in the States Index that details the constitutional and statutory religious freedom protections in each of the 50 states. Idaho ranked 8th in the nation based on a review of 50 safeguards.

What I found encouraging are the gains made in our state that have a positive impact on all people in Idaho. Last year, our state was ranked 13th and with important legislation passed, such as the Medical Ethics Defense Act, which respects and protects the conscious rights of our medical professionals, we continue to move up in the ranking. Religious liberty is universally important to all Americans regardless of one’s religious affiliation because it is connected to broad civil liberties including free speech, parental rights, academic freedom, and freedom of assembly. If the government can heavily regulate belief and conscience, our constitutional freedoms weaken over time. 

I’m proud of what we have done in recent years to improve our religious liberty protections. As lawmakers continue to work together, there are additional safeguards to consider as we look to securing an even greater future for the generations to come.

In 2025, nearly 14,000 weddings were conducted in our state with over $425 million spent on ceremonies and celebrations. However, faith-based businesses that provide goods or services for marriage ceremonies and celebrations have no protections if the requests conflict with their religious beliefs. Two Supreme Court cases, Masterpiece Cakeshop, LTD v Colorado Civil Rights Commission (2018) and 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis (2023), offer some First Amendment protections to wedding vendors, but a state law protecting the state’s bakers, photographers, florists, and other creative professionals could prevent years of frustrating litigation.  Mississippi and Arkansas have such laws in place, which provide guidance for what should be passed in our state.

Idaho has yet to pass a statute that states often refer to as “Pastor Protection Acts.” Because marriage may involve a civil contract and a religious sacrament, these statues protect members of the clergy, churches, and religious organizations from being forced to participate in the solemnization, formation, or celebration of marriages that violate sincerely held religious beliefs. In Idaho, couples have multiple alternatives to secure a wedding officiant without forcing members of the clergy to violate their views of the marriage union. Arkansas, for example, the number one state for religious liberty protections in this year’s index, passed a law protecting clergy from being forced to violate their deeply held convictions.

Public officials can solemnize weddings in Idaho but our state has yet to pass laws protecting the conscience rights of any officials who object to officiating marriages that conflict with their personal or religious convictions. Mississippi is one state that has moved to protect officials from being sanctioned or required to solemnize marriages that violate their conscience. Even with such laws in place, couples have multiple options available to legally marry while respecting the moral convictions of our public officials.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, several states barred religious gatherings from meeting while placing no restrictions on other establishments deemed “essential,” which included liquor stores, marijuana dispensaries and bicycle repair shops. In the wake of the pandemic, eighteen states, including Utah,  passed statutes that prohibit governments from treating houses of worship differently than similarly situated businesses. Idaho is not one of them. The Supreme Court ultimately ruled that government emergency orders could not single out religious institutions for harsher restrictions than those applied to comparable secular establishments. Codifying protections directly into state law creates an enduring barrier against future emergency mandates that might attempt to single out houses of worship and other religious gatherings. 

Many of the 50 safeguards measured in the index are currently in place for our state which ensures the people of Idaho can exercise their faith freely both in public and private without compromise. But there is more to be done, and it is incumbent on the lawmakers across the state to work diligently to protect those rights and to pass laws to ensure protections are upheld. Idaho can be number one in the rankings, but it will take the work of all us to achieve this worthy goal.

• • •

Ben Toews, is the Idaho State Senator for District 4.


Logo

copyright © 2026 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy 215 N. 2nd St. Coeur d'Alene, ID 83814
208-664-8176

Coeur d'Alene Press BBB Business Review