Property records at issue in murder trial
Attorneys sparred in court Thursday over the question of who really owned the Spirit Lake property that prosecutors said provided the motive for Neil Stratton to kill his mother.
Stratton, 53, is on trial for first-degree murder, burglary and destruction of evidence in connection with the death of his mother, 77-year-old Susan Stratton.
Prosecutors allege that Neil Stratton attacked his mother in the rental home they shared in Coeur d'Alene in the early hours of Sept. 18, 2025. Susan Stratton died from her injuries three weeks later.
The state argued that Neil Stratton relied on his mother to provide for him and that he killed her because she planned to sell the Spirit Lake property he stood to inherit, leaving him penniless.
Defense counsel contends that Neil Stratton legally owned the property, not his mother, and that he provided for her, not the other way around.
Coeur d'Alene attorney Jed Nixon took the stand Thursday to testify about records related to the property on Catbird Lane in Spirit Lake at issue in the case.
Susan Stratton purchased the 40-acre property in 2016 on behalf of a trust. That same year, an unrecorded quitclaim deed transferred the property from the trust into the sole ownership of Neil Stratton. In Idaho, unrecorded deeds are valid between the parties.
But Nixon said the property's ownership isn't clear-cut in this case. Another quitclaim deed, recorded with the county in 2021, transferred the property from the trust to Susan Stratton and Neil Stratton and "muddied" the waters.
Defense counsel argued that the 2016 deed was the controlling document and the subsequent deed didn't change Neil Stratton's sole ownership of the property.
Nixon said the fact that the 2021 deed was recorded gives it more legitimacy.
"I would say that would trump the other deed," he said.
The Spirit Lake property was later subdivided into smaller portions. In November 2023, Susan Stratton sold 20 acres of the property for $664,000.
Prosecutors questioned why the 2016 deed was never recorded with the county. Nixon said he couldn't think of a good reason a property owner wouldn't record the deed and acknowledged that hiding assets or avoiding taxation were possible reasons.
"There's something, for lack of a better word, shady going on," Nixon said.
Prosecuting attorney Art Verharen said defense counsel didn't disclose the 2016 deed until Oct. 2 of this year and that the state wasn't aware of its existence during grand jury proceedings in the spring.
"This unrecorded deed from Susan Stratton to her son saw the light of day about a month ago," he said.
Outside the presence of the jury, Verharen said defense attorney Ben Onosko had "crossed a line" by implying to jurors that the state had access to the 2016 deed earlier than it really did. He asked the court to hold Onosko in contempt for his remarks.
"His argument is contemptuous," Verharen said. "It's not appropriate. It's untruthful."
Onosko argued that the state possessed a different deed that predated the 2021 document, though not the 2016 record, which was not presented to the grand jury earlier this year. He said he made no distinction in court Thursday between that deed and the 2016 deed.
First District Judge Regina McCrea said it was "patently obvious to the court" that prosecutors didn't have the 2016 deed before Oct. 2. She said she wouldn't find Onosko in contempt.
"I don't agree that your conduct is contemptuous," she said.