Friday, November 20, 2026
36.0°F

EDITORIAL: Commissioner violated the sacred tradition of hunting

| November 20, 2026 1:00 AM

In North Idaho, hunting isn't just a hobby. It's a way of life and a sacred trust between the people and the place they live, where ethics and accountability are among the biggest lessons that are supposed to be learned by anyone who participates. 

Brody Harshbarger, a member of the Idaho Fish and Game Commission, broke that trust.

According to court records, Harshbarger agreed to plead guilty to hunting without a valid tag and shooting from or across a public highway. In exchange, five other misdemeanor charges were dismissed. On Wednesday, it was reported he resigned.

As part of the plea deal, Harshbarger will receive $1,000 in fines, six months of probation and a one-year suspension of his hunting privileges. 

The question of crime and punishment isn't really the issue here. While many of us disagree with plea agreements and pretrial settlements that often allow offenders to walk away with far less punishment than their actions may deserve, we also know the criminal justice system is imperfect. Cases are negotiated every day, and prosecutors and defense attorneys reach agreements for all sorts of reasons. 

The real issue is what happens next. 

These commissioners occupy a unique position in Idaho's hierarchy. They are not simply policymakers. They are stewards of a public trust. Millions of dollars generated through license sales, tags and conservation efforts are built upon a simple understanding between sportsmen and the state: everyone follows the same rules. 

And for Idaho hunters, those rules aren't suggestions. They're the foundation of the entire system. 

Hunting is ultimately a test of character. You have to follow the rules. You have to respect boundaries. You have to be honest, even when nobody is watching. 

If you can't do those things, you have no business taking the life of another living thing. Quite frankly, you don't deserve the privilege. 

That's why this case is bothering so many people right now. 

This man broke that trust, broke several rules and, like most commissioners, has likely spent years advocating for ethical hunting and responsible stewardship of wildlife. Yet here we are. 

Harshbarger was right to resign. There is no world in which a Fish and Game commissioner should be allowed to plead guilty to hunting crimes, accept a plea deal and then reassume a position of authority over Idaho hunters. 

Public officials are entrusted with authority because citizens believe they will model the standards expected of everyone else. When the official responsible for helping guide wildlife policy admits to violating hunting laws, the damage extends beyond the courtroom. It erodes confidence in the institutions charged with protecting Idaho's hunting heritage. 

Hunting is one of the defining traditions of Idaho. It is one of the reasons many people choose to live here, and one of the reasons others spend thousands of dollars every year traveling here. Those people expect accountability from the individuals entrusted with managing one of our state's most treasured resources. 

Accountability is for everyone, and the people of Idaho deserve better.


Logo

copyright © 2026 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy 215 N. 2nd St. Coeur d'Alene, ID 83814
208-664-8176

Coeur d'Alene Press BBB Business Review