Forensic analyst testifies in Stratton murder trial
A mountain bike and backpack owned by accused murderer Neil Stratton bear similarities to those seen in surveillance footage of a mystery cyclist prosecutors believe pedaled from Spirit Lake to the Coeur d'Alene home where Stratton allegedly attacked his mother, a forensic analyst said in court Wednesday.
Stratton, 53, is on trial for first-degree murder, burglary and destruction of evidence in connection with the death of his mother, 77-year-old Susan Stratton.
The state alleges that Neil Stratton attacked his mother in the rental home they shared in September 2025, causing the injuries that led to her death three weeks later. Prosecutors said Neil Stratton killed his mother because she planned to sell a Spirit Lake property he stood to inherit and then leave Idaho.
Rathdrum Police Chief Dan Haley, a detective with the Coeur d'Alene Police Department at the time of the attack, described his involvement in the investigation to jurors.
Haley was among the investigators who executed a search warrant on Susan Stratton's undeveloped property on Catbird Lane in Spirit Lake, where Neil Stratton typically spent several nights a week.
Inside a shipping container, police found a mountain bike that prosecutors said Neil Stratton bought the day before his mother was attacked. While part of the bike's seat was clean, Haley said another area was dusty.
"Clean and shiny indicated to me that it had been used recently," Haley said.
Detective Amy Knisley with the Coeur d'Alene Police Department told jurors that she had seized a backpack from the Catbird property.
Prosecutors said surveillance footage showed a person wearing a backpack riding a bike near the Catbird property after 8 p.m. on Sept. 17, 2025.
Investigators reportedly used footage from several businesses to follow the cyclist's journey from Spirit Lake to Coeur d'Alene, within half a mile of Susan Stratton's home. Eight hours later, the cyclist returned to Spirit Lake.
In early September, prosecutors said, Neil Stratton had researched how long it would take to walk from the Spirit Lake property to the Coeur d'Alene address.
Stratton's defense counsel has argued that the surveillance footage contains discrepancies and doesn't prove anything.
Prosecutors said the clearest footage was captured outside Intechtel on Government Way. Video played in court showed a cyclist wearing a dark jacket and a backpack pass by, heading south on Government Way.
Forensic analyst Edward Baker testified about the footage. Baker is a retired detective who worked for the Tacoma Police Department in Washington for 27 years and now owns Video Consultants Northwest.
"I do CSI stuff with video, basically," he told jurors.
Defense attorney Jay Logsdon compared Baker's analysis to that of a spot-the-difference puzzle in a children's magazine.
"That's what you do, at the end of all this," he said.
Baker analyzed the Intechtel footage and documented the bike and backpack's characteristics. He said the 8K video was high enough quality to allow a comparative analysis.
Baker also recreated the scene using Neil Stratton's bike. He compared the two videos and overlaid one on top of the other to see how the bikes lined up.
"I came to the conclusion that I couldn't rule out (Neil Stratton's) bicycle," he said.
When he analyzed the backpack seen in the surveillance footage, Baker said he identified 14 characteristics. Of those, 12 matched the backpack found at the Catbird property.
"There were enough characteristics that I felt you couldn't ignore the bike police had in their possession," he said. "The same is true for the backpack."