Transparency is best when it leaves no doubt
Transparency in government seems like a given these days, right?
With all the talk about government transparency, candidates promising openness, meetings being recorded and archived, and citizens demanding access to information, it would be easy to assume governments are doing everything possible to keep the public informed.
At The Press, we work to hold government accountable by attending public meetings, reviewing public records and asking questions. For decades, local newspapers have served as government watchdogs, helping ensure the public's business remains public.
To their credit, our local governments generally embrace that responsibility. They are typically receptive when our reporters call with questions. City council members answer their phones more often than not, and staff reports included in agenda packets are usually detailed.
Still, elected officials can always do more.
That brings us to the Dalton Gardens City Council, which tonight will consider repealing Resolution 2023-01, known as the "Transparency Resolution," and replacing it with a measure establishing compliance with Idaho law governing public notices, public records and municipal record retention.
The proposed Resolution 2026 states plainly: "The City shall comply with applicable Idaho statutes governing public notices, publication, electronic posting, public records, and municipal record retention, as those statutes may be amended."
That leaves no room for doubt or misunderstanding.
If this change increases transparency, that's a positive step. Resolution 2023-01 was well-intentioned, but some portions were a bit vague.
For example, the resolution states the city recognizes the need "to embrace and fully utilize technological improvement to keep the city on the cutting edge of government innovation." Recognizing a need, however, is not the same as requiring action.
Likewise, the resolution states that making financial documents, budgets and building permits available on the city's website would reduce the cost, time and effort required to respond to public records requests. It doesn't require making them available, but says doing so could save money and time.
Government policies should leave little room for uncertainty. Citizens should not have to guess what information will be available or what standards their elected officials will follow. The clearer those standards are, the better.
That's why replacing broad statements of intent with specific requirements matters.
North Idaho residents tend to trust their local governments, and for good reason: over time, those governments have shown they are trustworthy.
Mind you, no government can operate entirely in public. State law allows closed-door discussions, such as personnel matters, something the Coeur d'Alene City Council was scheduled to do last night. But those exceptions should remain just that: exceptions.
In summary, clear rules, records and communication strengthen public confidence. They also build public trust, which we all know is one of government's most valuable assets.