Friday, November 20, 2026
28.0°F

MY TURN: Idaho is more than its political stereotype

by ETHEL STEINMETZ MARMONT/My Turn
| November 18, 2026 1:00 AM

The editorial “Why the blue wave failed to wash over Idaho” confuses an election result with the identity of an entire state.

It depicts Idaho as a place defined by mining, logging, agriculture, hard work, self-reliance, and religious tradition. These are part of our history, but they are not our current story. In fact, history suggests that beginning in the 1980s, when the logging and mining industries declined and unions lost some political power, Idahoans began voting more predominantly Republican.

Today, healthcare, education, retail, construction, transportation, and tourism are major economic engines. Here in Kootenai County, Coeur d’Alene has become a tourism destination. Our economy increasingly depends on hotels, restaurants, recreation, retail, and services. Our state is attracting newcomers from across the country. Idaho is not the Great Redoubt, but rather an amalgamation of different beliefs, perspectives, and experiences.

But the editorial ignores another question: Why are we having difficulty keeping young families and graduates here?

Idaho's wages remain below the national average. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Idaho's average weekly wage in the fourth quarter of 2025 was $1,303, compared with $1,569 nationally — a difference of $266 per week. Young people need more than beautiful scenery and a low-tax slogan. They need good-paying jobs, career opportunities, affordable housing, and the ability to build a stable future.

Healthcare makes a difference, too. According to March of Dimes, Idaho has counties classified as maternity care deserts. These communities lack a local hospital or birth center providing obstetric care and obstetric clinicians. Idaho’s restrictive reproductive health laws and the resulting uncertainty for physicians are legitimate concerns for women and families deciding where to live, work, and raise children. These policies influence where young professionals choose to practice and where families choose to settle.

The editorial's treatment of Proposition 1 is equally incomplete. Its defeat does not mean Idaho women are satisfied with the state's restrictive reproductive health laws.

Powerful religious institutions spent heavily on the campaign. Attorney General Raúl Labrador issued an opinion allowing churches to use general funds to block the initiative without identifying individual donors. Voters deserved transparency about who was financing efforts to influence this debate and whether they were describing the initiative accurately or using disinformation to alter its true impact and demonize supporters.

Women in Idaho remain subject to a near-total abortion ban with narrow exceptions. Physicians still face legal uncertainty when treating patients with serious pregnancy complications. A woman experiencing a miscarriage or a dangerous pregnancy should not have to wonder whether her doctor can legally provide the care she needs.

Idaho belongs to all of us. History is not destiny. One election does not give any political party ownership of our future. If we want our children and grandchildren to stay, we must build a state where they can find affordable housing, earn a decent living, raise healthy families, and trust that their health and personal freedoms will be protected.

• • •

Ethel Steinmetz Marmont is a Coeur d’ Alene resident.


Logo

copyright © 2026 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy 215 N. 2nd St. Coeur d'Alene, ID 83814
208-664-8176

Coeur d'Alene Press BBB Business Review