Investigator, medical providers testify in Stratton murder trial
Interview footage played in court Monday showed the moment an investigator confronted Coeur d'Alene resident Neil Stratton about suspicions that he was behind a brutal attack on his mother.
Stratton, 53, is on trial for first-degree murder, burglary and destruction of evidence in connection with the death of his mother, 77-year-old Susan Stratton.
The state alleges that Neil Stratton attacked his mother in the Coeur d'Alene rental home they shared in September 2025, causing the injuries that led to her death three weeks later.
Prosecutors said Neil Stratton relied on his mother to provide for him and that he killed her because she planned to sell the Spirit Lake property he stood to inherit and then move to Missouri, leaving him in a financial bind.
Defense counsel has argued that Neil Stratton provided for his mother, not the other way around, and pointed to bad blood and financial disputes between Susan Stratton and other family members.
In court Monday, jurors watched a recording of Neil Stratton's interview with Alan Winstead, a lieutenant with the Coeur d'Alene Police Department.
During the recorded conversation, Neil Stratton said he wasn't home during the attack and had instead spent the night at the Spirit Lake property. He said he returned home the afternoon of Sept. 18, 2025 and found his mother injured.
Stratton theorized that his mother had interrupted a burglary. He told the investigator that his mom had left "everything" to him in her will.
"Do you feel like you're a suspect in this?" Winstead asked.
"I'm starting to," Stratton replied.
The circumstances of the crime were unusual, Winstead said, and the idea that a burglar had entered the home, attacked Susan Stratton and left after taking only the elderly woman's cell phone was implausible.
"Your mom's not in the drug world," he told Stratton. "This is no bar scene thing. She's an elderly lady living by herself in a very quiet neighborhood."
Winstead noted that Susan Stratton had recently mended her relationship with her adult daughter and had told friends of her plans to sell the Spirit Lake property.
He suggested that the person who attacked Susan Stratton might have intended to kill her or might have acted out of anger without the intent to kill.
"Everybody in your family has told us that you love your mother," he said. "I believe that."
He said Stratton's demeanor changed during that part of the interview.
"He was either looking down or closing his eyes," Winstead told jurors. "His face was trembling."
Medical providers described Susan Stratton's condition after the attack, as well as their interactions with Neil Stratton.
Firefighter and paramedic Lavoryn Nguyen responded to the crime scene. He said he entered Susan Stratton's bedroom and saw a "substantial amount of blood," much of it on the bed. Susan Stratton was on the floor, breathing shallowly and fast. There was a wound on the side of her head.
"When she would open her eyes, she had a fixed gaze," he said. "Her eyes were up and to the right. They weren't looking like a fully conscious person."
Anneka Garrison worked as a nurse at Kootenai Health in 2025 and cared for Susan Stratton in the ICU. She said she spent considerable time in the hospital room with Neil Stratton, who visited daily.
When other family members were present, Garrison said Neil Stratton appeared upset. When he was alone, his demeanor was flat.
Prosecuting attorney Art Verharen asked if Neil Stratton ever inquired about whether his mother might remember the attack, should she regain consciousness.
"He did," Garrison said.