Man who shot up Hayden Lake neighborhood may see probation
The man who shot up a Hayden Lake house last year with a semi-automatic rifle and who has been in the county jail since November was a University of Idaho physics major, an outstanding student and Afghan war veteran, his mother said.
Justin A. Hill, 32, was sentenced Friday to between three and eight years in prison, but First District Judge John Mitchell retained jurisdiction. That allows Hill to straighten out his drug problems in a yearlong rehabilitation program.
After that, Hill could serve the remainder of his time, or he could be placed on probation.
Hill’s mother told the court that her son was the light of her life, and an above-average student who earned top grades at the U of I.
“He was my shining star,” Geri Hill said. “Somehow he got in trouble with drugs and had a bad incident.”
Hill was arrested Nov. 14 by a SWAT team near his family’s Hayden Lake home for allegedly threatening to shoot his sister and mother while in a drug-induced rage, according to police reports. Hill allegedly used an M-16 style rifle to riddle a Subaru Forester and a Subaru Impreza with bullets and spray the inside of his family’s home. Some of the rounds struck neighboring homes, police said.
As part of a plea agreement, prosecutors dismissed five felony counts including attempted murder, and Hill pleaded guilty to assault and discharging a firearm indoors.
According to court testimony, Hill served two front-line tours in Afghanistan with the Marines, which included clearing minefields with a dog. He attended North Idaho College and the university and had no criminal history.
Witnesses said he was funny, patient, a good friend and a good listener who always had your back.
“He was openly kind-hearted,” former co-worker and friend Leslie Coleman said.
Former boss Robin Erny said Hill was reliable and engaging with customers.
“He always hated drugs,” he said.
Prosecutors said Hill didn’t take full responsibility for his actions, that probation would be too light a penalty because of the seriousness of the charges, but acknowledged that PTSD played a role.
Public defenders said Hill’s history of public service should be recognized.
“He has served his country and there is no reason to believe he will be like other criminal defendants,” attorney Linda Payne said. “Sitting in prison is not going to help him.”
Although Kootenai County has no veterans court — the nearest one is in District 2 in Lewiston — and Hill is not eligible for mental health court because of his PTSD, Payne said her client is eligible for drug court.
Before sentencing, Mitchell acknowledged Hill’s meritorious service and minimal criminal history.
“His criminal history is fishing without a license,” Mitchell said.
The judge said other veterans with similar issues were successful on probation.
“You were a good student and a good Marine,” the judge said. “I want you to give it your all.”