Thursday, November 19, 2026
30.0°F

No headline

| February 18, 2020 12:00 AM

SOCIALISM: He said what?

John Strobel wrote a guest opinion I cannot follow. He fabricates an American socialism that none of the Founders or any politician recognized even until today. He alleges the American socialism is unrelated to that in Cuba, Venezuela, the USSR, or Nazi Germany but never explains the difference.

His first shot at explaining this is American socialism “built us roads, highways and bridges, and provides funds to maintain all of these critical structures so critical to the success of capitalism.” So, the Egyptians were socialists because they collectively built the pyramids? The Romans were socialists because they taxed their people and built roads and bridges all over Europe? I have a degree in European History and never got this angle.

American socialism “keeps our roads clear of snow and provides specialists who respond to avalanches.” From the time countries plowed a road in winter they were socialistic. From this I have no idea what his view of American socialism is.

But here is the point of this nonsense: “So Sen. Risch, Idaho voters deserve to hear the truth, which you heard during the impeachment trial. With your vote to acquit the president, you assured your place in the history books.” What does this unrelated, disjointed reference to impeachment have to do with anything Strobel was trying to say?

He finishes with “all the lies coming out of the White House. One of those lies is about what socialism is and isn’t.”

This incoherent mess is a result of Trump Derangement Syndrome (TDS). The Press needs to tighten up its standards for an Op/Ed.

TOM LAWRENCE

Hayden

SOCIALISM: Look it up

This letter is in response to J. Strobel’s Op/Ed on 2/14. No, in my opinion, “American Socialism” is much worse than what you think it is. His article sounds like he’s parroting Obama — you didn’t build this — American socialism has. Then I want to know where all our tax money went for highways, bridges, schools, colleges, police, fire and EMT services.

Hoover Institution article by Paul Gregory, May 10, 2016, states:

“Economic, political and social systems are like three-legged stools. The three legs of the capitalist or free enterprise stool are democratic/pluralistic public choice, a non-interventionist state, and a rule of law that protects personal and economic liberty. The three legs of the socialist stool are a one-party state, pervasive intervention in economic affairs, and a lack of rule of law to guard personal and economic freedom.”

Socialism as defined by Webster: 1. a theory or system of social organization in which the means of production and distribution of goods are owned and controlled collectively or by the government. 2. (in Marxist theory) the stage following capitalism in the transition of a society to communism, characterized by the imperfect implementation of collectivist principles.” Definitely not my idea of a free United States of America!

My Social Security is not a hand out — I paid into it my entire working life!

Thank you, Sen. Risch for stating the obvious. There are still several statements in J. Strobel’s article I would like to address, not the least of which is his statement about “lies,” but I think I have run out of allocated words. DO YOUR HOMEWORK AMERICANS!

LAGONDA McDONALD, S.B.

Coeur d’Alene

SOCIALISM: Cancer on society

After reading the guest opinion by John Strobel I was blown away by the gobbily goop he spewed about the great wonders of “American Socialism.” What a crock. Socialism is a cancer on any society. To compare it to building roads, bridges and other infrastructure is obscured at best and downright dumb!

Comparing Socialism to getting a retirement check is beyond absurd (in case you didn’t notice we paid for it, it’s not a gift from a socialistic government) or to compare it to income tax or property tax. Obviously he does not know anything about what history has taught us about the next step once a society is lured into socialism.

Take from the dirty “nasty rich” and give to the poor who refuse to work. Punish the rich, how dare they work night and day to get ahead and then have the nerve to want to keep what they make. That’s always how the naive people are sucked in. Then the day comes sooner or later when other people’s money runs out.

If socialism is so wonderful, how come we have people leaving socialist countries all over the world and sneaking into America? Socialism is just one small step away from Communism. If anyone wants to find out where it leads just read Victor Kravchenko’s book, “I Chose Freedom.” If that don’t wake you up nothing will.

C.R. BECKER

Coeur d’Alene


Logo

copyright © 2026 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy 215 N. 2nd St. Coeur d'Alene, ID 83814
208-664-8176

Coeur d'Alene Press BBB Business Review