Wednesday, November 18, 2026
43.0°F

Sex with child case sentence reduced

| February 1, 2020 12:00 AM

By RALPH BARTHOLDT

Staff Writer

The sentence was reduced Friday for a 49-year-old Rathdrum man serving 25 years for having sex with a child.

First District Judge Cynthia K.C. Meyer, who sentenced Alpha L. Roberts to 10 years fixed and 15 years indeterminate last year, reduced the fixed portion — the time Roberts must serve — to seven years.

The decision came after Meyer heard testimony from Roberts, the victim’s mother, and from defense attorney Sean Walsh as part of a post-sentence hearing in Coeur d’Alene.

Walsh said prosecutors gave an impassioned plea during last October’s sentencing, which overlooked or misrepresented many facts in the case.

“The court didn’t have all the facts available at sentencing,” Walsh said.

He asked that Meyer reduce the fixed portion of the sentence to five years, which would allow Roberts to immediately enroll in sex offender treatment programs.

The programs aren’t available to inmates until they get closer to parole eligibility.

Prosecutors defended the arguments presented at the October hearing and said the judge had all the relevant information at sentencing, including that the 14-year-old victim was developmentally disabled and that Roberts had taken advantage of the child.

Calling the judge’s October sentence “well reasoned and supported by the evidence,” deputy prosecutor Katherine Murdock reminded the court that Roberts’ presentence report recommended a prison sentence, and that a 10-year fixed sentence was within guidelines.

“The sentence reflects the adult’s behavior in this matter,” Murdock said.

But the new evidence, including the mother’s testimony, Meyer said, warranted a partial sentence reduction.

“I’m not going to knock off five years,” Meyer said. “That’s too much.”

The conviction and original sentence reflected the crime, Meyer said.

“It does go back to Roberts’ conduct,” Meyer said.

Reducing the fixed portion would still fall within sentencing guidelines, ensure the victim’s safety, allow Roberts to wait a few more years for treatment and it would leave Roberts’ release up to the parole board.

Roberts is serving his time at the Idaho Correctional Institution in Orofino.


Logo

copyright © 2026 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy 215 N. 2nd St. Coeur d'Alene, ID 83814
208-664-8176

Coeur d'Alene Press BBB Business Review