Jeweler still out in cold with claim being denied
By DEVIN WEEKS
Staff Writer
COEUR d’ALENE — Clark's Diamond Jewelers is still fighting the claim of a Midwestern weather company that it didn't snow at least 3 inches on Jan. 11.
"This is kind of our worst nightmare," store owner "Jeweler" Jane Clark said Friday. "It's the worst thing that could have happened."
Clark's promised customers it would refund the cost of purchases made between Nov. 22 and Dec. 31 if snowfall reached 3 inches or more that day as part of the Let it Snow promotion.
As those who were in town that day know, it did indeed snow. Longtime local climatologist Cliff Harris, who operates a weather station with a Doppler radar at his home in central Coeur d’Alene and checks it six times a day, measured 3.6 inches of snow in that 24-hour timeframe.
It was reason to rejoice as $500,000 was expected to go back into the pockets of Clark's customers. But Clark's insurance company declined to pay the claim after using measurement data provided by Illinois-based Weather Command, which initially recorded just 1.8 inches of snow that day.
"We went ahead and immediately asked for the audit," Clark said, adding that once reviewed, the data returned with a report of 2.3 inches.
"They have denied the claim," she said. "We are working now with legal professionals to try to resolve this matter … We have submitted a lot of information that is contrary to the 2.3 inches."
She said it looks like it comes down to contracts and "who gets to measure and who gets to say" what the final outcome will be.
An update on Clark's Facebook page explains that the promotion was only possible "because we first obtained, at considerable cost, a weather and specialty insurance policy to cover the refunds in the event of the snowfall we all hoped for."
“It’s not a great outcome. It’s been very stressful around here,” Clark said. “We want to thank all of our customers for being so understanding in this process. We believe the insurance company owes our customers refunds.”
Harris, who has been measuring weather and precipitation in Coeur d'Alene for nearly 30 years of his 68 years in the business, is "more than a little ticked off" about what has transpired. He confirmed Friday that he personally and separately from Clark's intends to sue Weather Command "for a huge amount of money," $1.5 million.
Harris said he measured in several different places that day, recording up to 4.2 inches "but I took the lowest measurement just so somebody couldn't say I over-measured," he said.
Harris personally shoveled his driveway the night before the 11th to be sure it was clear at midnight. Not only did he have to shovel twice the next day, but reports came in from surrounding weather stations that all recorded at least 3 inches that day, Harris said.
“They don't have a leg to stand on,” Harris said. “We’ll blow them away with 1,000 witnesses.
“I’m not going to quit this,” he said. “We’re not going to take 'no' for an answer.”
Weather Command did not reply to a request for comment by deadline Friday.