Lack of bids pushes Cd'A to negotiate a better deal
By CRAIG NORTHRUP
Staff Writer
When the city of Coeur d’Alene opened the bidding for contractors to fight over a future 12-acre park along the Atlas Mill waterfront, city officials felt optimistic about their chances the free market would deliver a competitive bid. With a budget of $6 million provided by ignite cda, Coeur d’Alene’s urban renewal agency, leaders described the park’s prospects as hopeful.
“We had a good turnout of prospective bidders that day,” city administrator Troy Tymesen said after the Sept. 13 walk-through, a formality that serves as a key indicator of private interest as the bidding process begins. “We had about 10 representatives there on the 13th. So after bidding opens, we’ll bring their bids to the ignite [cda] meeting and then to City Council.”
Those hopes vanished when bidding opened to the sound of silence.
Anticipating as many as 10 bids for the project, the city received only one: Cameron Reilly Construction placed a base bid of $6.6 million plus $1.2 million in nonessential buildouts. The total price was $1.8 million more than the budget.
“It was very unexpected,” Tymesen later said. “We were all expecting a stronger turnout, but that happens sometimes in the bidding process.”
The project was stymied, Tymesen speculated, because of the complexities and sheer magnitude of the project, which will involve clearing and grubbing, mass excavation and embankment, extending Suzanne Road, building a parking lot, building a concrete plaza, building a shared-use path and sidewalks, constructing a masonry restroom and a pole building, installing an irrigation pump system, establishing rock landscape walls, installing water, storm and sewer lines, stabilizing the shoreline with rockery walls, restoring a beach, reinforcing water access, installing a wood log boom and pilings, landscaping, and sewer work, among other needs.
“One could speculate,” Tymesen said, “the project had a few too many moving pieces. “So the earthwork companies might have said, ‘Hey, we don’t build buildings; we move earth. The same contractors looking at stabilizing the shoreline might not have been able to do the sewer work. It’s a big project.”
“[I was] disappointed and a little surprised,” Council member Kiki Miller said, since 10 contractors were at the pre-construction meeting. But everyone is busy and facing industry challenges.”
“The project has many complex elements to it,” Mayor Steve Widmyer said, “and I believe that limited the number of contractors. I do believe that we will be able to negotiate a contract to start the project.”
Open negotiations are now a probable likelihood, as the council will vote tonight whether or not to reject the Cameron Reilly bid and hit the open market. Idaho law allows municipalities to circumvent the bidding process if no viable bids are received, allowing City Hall to then negotiate with contractors face-to-face. Cameron Reilly is still in the mix to earn the job, Tymesen said.
“A lot of times, with these moving parts, contractors can’t always foresee what their sub-contractors might do,” Tymesen said. “And a lot of times, in the bidding process, they won’t be able to get quotes from their people until the last minute.”
In some cases, the very last minute. Another contractor, T. LaRiviere, submitted a bid less than one minute after the process closed, thus prohibiting it from being considered. Parks Department director Bill Greenwood wrote in his report to the council that T. LaRiviere’s pricing was an indicator the city and a contractor can get the project done within the $6 million budget.
In other words, the Atlas Waterfront Park project is anything but dead.
“I’m confident there are still opportunities to get the project done,” Miller said.
Widmyer agreed. “I do believe that we will be able to negotiate a contract to start the project,” the mayor said.