Property rights fight evolves along popular lake drive
By BRIAN WALKER
Staff Writer
COEUR d'ALENE — Brian Oberholzer wanted to give folks a slice of heaven that's giving neighbors hell.
Oberholzer said he purchased two quarter-acre lots along popular Coeur d'Alene Lake Drive with a quaint 1960s-era A-frame structure that was the former Apache Rock Shop. His goal: Earning rental income while giving the renters stunning lake views.
"I took on a spot that was for sale for years and nothing was happening with it," he said. "It doesn't have septic and running water, but that didn't scare me. Even with limited resources, I thought I could solve those problems and share this little slice of heaven on Lake Coeur d'Alene.
"I'm going to figure it out to make it work."
However, what Oberholzer has allowed there — three old RVs and an old school bus that's been converted into living space — isn't working for lakefront neighbors who view the property as an eyesore, environmental concern and detriment to property values.
Several neighbors took those concerns to the Kootenai County commissioners, only to be reminded by county staff that Oberholzer isn't breaking any current land-use codes with two vehicles per lot.
Code also doesn't define a length of time for temporary use of the property for the vehicles, so neighbors' concerns about the vehicles being on the property for an extended period of time without being moved or serviced and no septic or running water couldn't be acted on, either.
However, a proposed code change is in the works to define "intermittent use." The proposal limits the timeframe to up to 90 consecutive days, followed by 30 consecutive days of non-use. The temporary use of an RV in the same location would also not exceed 180 days in a calendar year.
Public hearings on the proposal will be held on dates to be determined this spring before both the planning commission and county commissioners.
"It could easily be June before it becomes law," community development director David Callahan said. "It would give us a handle on what intermittent means so we can have more enforcement."
Callahan said that if the proposal is approved, Oberholzer will have to abide by the new law.
Neighbors also brought to the county's attention a Craigslist ad Oberholzer posted for tent camping on the property, but both Oberholzer and code compliance officer Jennifer Strampher said the ad was taken down when it was obvious that the additional use would draw compliance red flags.
"(Oberholzer) was cooperative when I contacted him," Strampher said. "Once he was made aware of the rules he seemed to want to be cooperative and follow the ordinance."
Oberholzer said he also complied when the county asked him to move one of the RVs to come into compliance of two RVs per lot.
Greg Delavan, among the neighboring property owners who has concerns, said he's also been on the other side of the property rights debate. He said he understands that Oberholzer is just trying to make money off land he purchased, but it also appears he's taking advantage of the gray areas of the law — which is ultimately his right to do.
"I'm all about property rights, but when it creates a nuisance that's where it should end," Delavan said. "If there's people living there without sewage, what's going on?"
Callahan said the quagmire typifies "weirdness" on land-use issues that are expected to become more common amid the county's rapid growth and Idaho's environment of limited regulations.
"We may not have had issues historically, but as we become more populated it'll become more of an issue," he said. "The code needs to catch up."
Oberholzer said that when he purchased the property, he realized there may be challenges gaining septic approval based on the previous owners' hurdles, but was still hopeful for a solution. The property's rocky terrain makes it a challenge for services, he said.
Oberholzer said he was recently notified by Panhandle Health District of that agency's concerns over a composting toilet in the A-frame that he is remodeling. Oberholzer said that while records confirm there was such a toilet in the structure before, he took it out during the remodel.
"There was just a reasoned assumption that there's still a composting toilet in there," Oberholzer said.
He said the A-frame is unoccupied. The occupants of the RVs make due with the lack of services by utilizing water holding tanks on the property, bringing in filtered water and one renter utilizes a public restroom down the street.
Oberholzer said the RVs are there for the winter season only.
"In a couple months they'll all be moved," he said.
He said he'll increase the rates over the summer during tourist season and promote the dock amenity across the road for lakeside gatherings.
Oberholzer said he wishes neighbors had approached him rather than present their concerns to the county first. He said he plans to reach out to start the dialogue, including an idea to tap into their water system for a fee. He also wants to explore the idea of tiny homes on the properties.
"I'm sensitive to what they are saying," he said. "I understand concerns of blight and lowering property values, but my hands are tied. If I could have a proper water source and septic, I could have a nice cabin there. I want to talk to them and look for viable solutions."
However, he also said "eyesores" can be subjective. He said he has also received praises for at least attempting to make use of the property rather than it sitting idle.
"I admit old RVs are not pretty, but I'm also trying to make a buck and to provide a service," he said.