Two votes finally settle election flap
By BRIAN WALKER
Staff Writer
HAYDEN LAKE — After four months, red flags thrown by a former state legislator, a court decision and a re-election, a winner in the Hayden Lake Irrigation District board election has finally emerged.
By two votes.
Incumbent Doris Fleming's 33 votes in Tuesday's re-election nipped Matthew Alexander's 31 to finally settle last November's election, which ended in a 10-10 tie.
The result came after a protest from former legislator Ed Morse that he and some other property owners were unlawfully denied the right to vote in November.
"More people had the freedom to vote," said Branden Rose, the district's administrator, referring to Tuesday's vote.
After November's tie vote, the district sought a court order to hold a coin toss to settle it. However, Morse, who owns A2Z Storage on Ramsey Road, sued the district to stop the coin flip because he believes he was denied the right to vote.
Judge John Mitchell ruled that Morse had a right to intervene in the case and stop the coin toss.
The district then agreed to hold the re-election rather than take the matter to trial.
The court ruling also allowed all property owners, regardless of whether they live in the district, to vote in the election.
It directed the district to develop an election guide to train poll workers to prevent more voting mistakes in future irrigation district elections.
"Thank you for getting more voters out," Rose told The Press. "As long as you owned property in the district and took the oath, everybody was allowed to vote."
Both Fleming and Alexander served on the board as chairpersons from November until Tuesday, so both were up to speed on district matters until the fate of the three-year seat was determined.
"Luckily, the other two board members had a quorum and never needed a tie-breaking vote," Rose said. "I believe both had the best interests of the district in their heart."
With irrigation districts, the chairperson votes only to break a tie.
Rose said that if the re-election had also ended in a tie, the matter would have headed back to court for a coin toss.
Fleming and Alexander couldn't be reached for comment on Wednesday.