Coeur d'Alene Press Newspaper | CDAPress.com

Local and National News - Kootenai County, Idaho

Consultant: Cd'A 'recession-proof'

Posted: Wednesday, May 07, 2008 - 11:32:43 pm PDT
Email this story Printer friendly version
By SEAN GARMIRE
Staff writer 
JEROME A. POLLOS/Press
Debi Camarda and her daughter, Brooklyn, 4, relax in the kiddie pool Wednesday at Triple Play's Raptor Reef.

Number of jobs in area has consistently risen in past year

COEUR d'ALENE -- The U.S. economy is tumbling into a full-blown recession this year -- it may be there already. But according to some regional economic pundits, with its diversified industry, North Idaho may sail through the doldrums.

Bureau of Labor statistics show that even as housing starts flatline and gas prices skyrocket, the number of jobs in Coeur d'Alene has consistently risen in the past year.

Based on those upward employment trends, Mark Hovind, a Nevada business consultant and president of JobBait.com, placed Coeur d'Alene on a list of 27 "recession-proof" areas in the U.S.

Hovind, who has made a career of helping competitive business executives find employers, crunched Bureau of Labor statistics taken from 400 metropolitan areas for the list.

The cities on the list are those in which the number of jobs outpaced growth in the workforce. The data were collected over several years -- including during the recessions of 1990 and 2001 -- ending in 2007.

According to the list, other recession-proof areas include Billings, Mont., Bend, Ore., and Bellingham, Wash.

Jonathan Coe, president of the Coeur d'Alene Area Chamber of Commerce, said "it makes me a little nervous to use (recession-proof), but I to think we do have a strong economy, and one that is fairing well in this downturn."

The term "recession-proof," Hovind said, may be misleading, and "recession-resistant is technically the correct term."

Hovind's data show Coeur d'Alene's fastest growth in the tourism sector, which "went wild" with 1,800 new jobs over the last 12 months.

"Why is Coeur d'Alene sailing through these recessions?" he asked, "in a word: Leisure."

Kathryn Tacke, regional economist for the Idaho Department of Labor, said the tourism industry is only one sector contributing to the overall growth in the area, and the reasons for the city's relative stability are complicated.

Tacke added health care and manufacturing to the economic sectors contributing to the upward trending job market.

"Manufacturing is our largest sector," she said. "It has some weakness from the timber industry, but other sectors in manufacturing are continuing to grow and are offsetting those timber job losses."

Aside from contributing more jobs, manufacturing usually pays higher wages, she said.

According to Tacke, Kootenai County's manufacturing jobs averaged $35,925 annually, while the leisure industry paid less than half -- $14,594, including tips.

With newly recruited companies in Kootenai County, like Amulet Manufacturing, or existing growing ones, like Transtector Systems, the market is experiencing a "very healthy increase," Tacke said.

Nationwide over the last 10 years, the U.S. has lost 3 million jobs in manufacturing, while Kootenai County has added about 1,000 with 24 percent growth, Tacke said.

Coeur d'Alene's higher-than-normal senior population may also bolster the area's economy.

Retiree income tends to be stable and does not fluctuate with the economy, Tacke said. Additionally, as those seniors and retirees grow older, they will spend more and more money on health care.

"Think about what's going to happen to the Baby Boomers 20 years from now," she said. "We're getting to the point when the health care industry is only going to grow."

Despite health care growth, Tacke said it is becoming even harder for workers to find jobs offering health care benefits.

While manufacturing and health care sectors show signs of stability, growth in the tourism industry is not so certain.

Economists theorize that rising gas and airline ticket prices will deter tourists from making their summer visit to Coeur d'Alene. But the weakening dollar could ease the passage for overseas travelers to the area.

"Nobody knows what's going to happen with the tourist industry," Tacke said. It "is the brightest star during the next year. But it also could be one of our biggest disappointments."

On Wednesday afternoon, the indoor water park at Hayden's Triple Play echoed with the sound of children who splashed and floated in the warm water.

Families came and went throughout the day, which is typical year-around for business at the amusement park, said marketing director Jennifer Ross.

Like most businesses in North Idaho's tourist industry, Triple Play is busiest during the summer months, but Ross said with a bowling alley and indoor water park tourists from across the Northwest visit regularly through the winter.

Although many families visiting the park come from Spokane, Seattle, Montana, Portland and Boise, there are a growing number of Canadians.

Ross also credits Silverwood Theme Park, which has partnered with Triple Play, for a steady stream of hotel patrons during the summer.

"Summer is already booked," she said. "It's definitely not going down."

Information:

http://www.jobbait.com

Sean Garmire can be reached at 664-8176, ext. 2009 or at sgarmire@cdapress.com.


Email this story Printer friendly version
POST YOUR OPINION
View all of the latest commented stories!
You must register with a valid email to post comments. Only your Member ID will be posted with the comments.

Registered users sign in here:

Become a Registered User

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
 

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

 

"A good community newspaper is a community in conversation with itself." - Walter Lippmann

The Press invites you to contribute your online comments, with positive statements whenever possible and, when necessary, your constructive, negative thoughts.

Commenting Rules
NEW- You must REGISTER in order to post on this forum. None of the information you provide will be used for anything that could be considered commercial in nature. The Press simply uses this information as a means to identify the poster.
- Do not use the comments area to promote commercial ventures.
- No libel (that means no NAME CALLING, OR USING PRIVATE CITIZEN'S NAMES)
- Use good taste
- Be positive whenever possible
- Do not Spam - post an advertisement or flood forum with the same message.
- Do not type entire post in CAPITALS - it means you are screaming. 
- THINK BEFORE YOUPOST and ask yourself these questions;
Is it a positive remark?
Will I be hurting anyone?
Children can come to this site, is it appropriate for their eyes?
Most importantly, would I want my name on this forum?

RD wrote on May 9, 2008 10:34 PM:

" I have news for you, "Wow da," and get a real name to facilitate communication! DA is correct and you are very wrong. What he, DA, is saying is that there is an actual definition for a recession and we are not in a recession...BY DEFINITION. You personally believe a recession means something like, "Wow, everyone on TV is saying things are bad and I hate Bush so we must be in a recession." (Pretty close to your reality I am betting.) In the real world, though, a recession is DEFINED by 2 consecutive quarters of negative economic growth. Stick with me here, you might just learn something. So, DA is right in telling you that we are NOT in a recession right now. Might we go into one? Maybe, but signs are pointing away from the likelyhood. And, if we do go into a recession, understand that they are part of the normal economic cycle. We have had about a dozen recessions since WWII. "

wow da wrote on May 9, 2008 1:46 PM:

" What are my qualifications? Why, my quals are that I am a citizen that has two eyes so that I may see. Two ears so I can hear.

What I don't have, which you so apparently do have, is a truly amazing set of blinders.

Perhaps you have the gift of willingness to believe that which is just not so.

Self-delusion is an ugly thing. You need to see about having yours removed. "

to wow da wrote on May 9, 2008 1:21 PM:

" What exactly are your qualifications for declaring the economic recession? Current numbers show that the economy has grown in the 1st qtr and will likely be revised even higher. Are you sure your information is correct? Or are you just repeating what you've heard? "

wow da wrote on May 9, 2008 12:18 PM:

" You really have the rosiest of glasses, don't you? Of COURSE we're in a recession. Just because Bush can't tell the truth doesn't mean that it isn't the truth. "

Observer wrote on May 9, 2008 11:23 AM:

" Where are all the SOLD signs? "

da wrote on May 9, 2008 9:22 AM:

" Can I please buy, rent or borrow the Press' crystal ball. To say the U.S. economy in tumbling into a full blown recession this year is irresponsible. What recession?? The last time I checked a recession is 2 consecutive quarters where the GDP is negative. Q1 of 2008 had a positive GDP and the stock markets are fairing well, meaining folks are still willing to invest their money. Oil is way up, the dollar is way down (part of the reason why oil is way up), but we are not in a recession. I am not saying that the worst is past us, and we may indeed see some harder times and future GDP decreases, but this sounds more like a prediction than news, especially the first sentance on the feature artlicle. This article reads like all other media features trying to paint a doom and gloom situation. P.S. Nothing is recession proof. "

BE wrote on May 9, 2008 12:59 AM:

" CDA will continue growing and deepening its economy, but probably with a significant "blood transfusion." Locals who cannot afford or cannot compete economically the "new CDA" will leave and be repalced with transplants from areas more expensive (Seattle, Portland, Bay Area, SoCal, etc.) and by individuals with capital and skill sets that offer them advantages with what CDA offers. Not opinion, simply the way economic dynamics work.

The key challenge is for those who are currently local. product. Are they willing to upgrade? Can they do what it takes to afford CDA? Are they able to take advantage of CDA? Are they and their skills a fit for the new CDA?

We tend to mix the two: the city and its inhabitants. When life is pretty stable, the differences between the two are blurred. Now is not such a time. Migration in and out of CDA means changing blood. If the LCDC continues on course, the new CDA will continue to thrive but with a different cast of characters and a different lifestyle/culture...for better or worse.
"

vicki wrote on May 8, 2008 6:28 PM:

" Cda is a beautiful place to visit, and while the tourist indusrty may be providing 1800 jobs over the last 12 months, I'm sure most of them are $3.50 an hour. "Right to Work" is a joke. It's a place to live if you're rich. If not, you're a slave to the rich and the tourist. Sorry guys. I was born there, so I know. But I'll still come back to visit in 7 years when I'm finished with college! "

vicki wrote on May 8, 2008 6:21 PM:

" Cda is a beautiful place to visit, and while the tourist indusrty may be providing 1800 jobs over the last 12 months, I'm sure most of them are $3.50 an hour. "Right to Work" is a joke. "

RD wrote on May 8, 2008 2:31 PM:

" I knew all the whiners would gather under this article. How I wish I could print the word "winners" instead. Listen people, it is up to you to improve your standing in life. Not the government, not your employer, and not even your mommy! Not making enough money? Turn off your TV and read some books. Improve yourself so that employers will have a reason to pay you more. Or better yet, take the risk of becoming self employed and you will learn real quick why most successful business owners are no fans of big government. Are you broke? Here's a fool proof idea: Spend just 90% of every dollar you take in and save the other 10%. A funny thing will begin to happen. You won't notice much difference between spending $90 instead of $100, and pretty soon you will actually have a bizarre thing in the bank...called money. We are not presently in a recession. Not locally, not nationally. And if we do slip into one, remember, they are a natural part of a free economy and how you fare through it will be up to you...not any politician or employer. "

dj wrote on May 8, 2008 1:54 PM:

" as a fulltime resident here- the tourist industry does nothing but create a disappointment to me -- i am hoping for an uncrowded summer season, and you can bet it will be off from last season-- it has to the way things are going unless folks use their stimulus to take a trip (dang it-i hope not). "

Moses Lake wrote on May 8, 2008 1:37 PM:

" If living in CDA has people strapped for money, why not move? Moses Lake is begging for qualified workers. General labor wage is $18 to $30 per hour. REC, MicroSoft, etc. are pumping hundreds of millions in the area. Workers are needed here. It's not paradise like CDA, but if a job is what you want or need, here it is. "

average joe wrote on May 8, 2008 11:05 AM:

" Uh look at the tourism that CDA is trying to attract with the large upscale communities and the upscale shops downtown. Do you think these people care about recession??? These are not the average Joes that are banking on there stimulus checks. "

well..... wrote on May 8, 2008 10:22 AM:

" If you have pleanty of money you won't see the hard times, but the less you have the harder you get hit as time goes by. "

Fred Smith wrote on May 8, 2008 10:18 AM:

" Lets see, 42-48%, depending on what data you use, of employment in KC is construction and real estate related. The real estate market crashed with the worst yet to come as more Alt-A paper recasts in 2008-9 than 2006-7. Every construction person I talk to is still not working and blaming it on the snow!

With no more logging and little mining, and the fact that we wont make it by selling stuff to each other, this area only has tourism and manufacturing to bring in outside dollars...you know from those poor saps in the non "recession proof" areas. Sure it wont be as bad as Michigan, but to say we are recession proof is silly. The American consumerist society is in for a rude awakening! "

yep wrote on May 8, 2008 9:32 AM:

" Hey, M, don't you know that reality has never mattered to Bush? "

M wrote on May 8, 2008 9:11 AM:

" It's the Bush mentality: if I don't SAY recession, we won't be IN a recession. "

shari wrote on May 8, 2008 8:50 AM:

" Can't find a job? Look! Center partners is always hiring, create a job!shovel sidewalks, mow lawns, There are ways to make money "

well wrote on May 8, 2008 8:35 AM:

" Since the native population can't seem to compete with the out of state money, maybe they should leave. "

volder wrote on May 8, 2008 8:23 AM:

" more false clams to bring in out of state money to drive out or enslave the native population "

hey wrote on May 8, 2008 8:22 AM:

" Hope you're all enjoying your minimum wage service jobs, you 'Right To Work' folks! "

ATHOL MAN wrote on May 8, 2008 7:49 AM:

" YOU WISH, STILL CAN'T FIND A JOB HERE, I'M BEHIIND 3 MONTHS ON MY TRAILER PAYMENT.... "

gw wrote on May 8, 2008 7:39 AM:

" Leisure business is the next thing to slave labor, poor pay no benifits and hard work. I can not beleive this "moron" calls this area recession proof. The pay here sucks and I feel sorry for anyone that has to struggle here with the recession proof jobs they have. I am so grateful I do not have to work at one of these recession proof employers. "

Bob Loblaw wrote on May 8, 2008 7:37 AM:

" Don't worry - be happy. What a bunch of happy joy-joy psychobabble. It's probably just to get us used to the idea that our property taxes are going to rise no matter how bad the economy gets. And renters - in case you think that the school levies aren't paid by you - guess again. "

peter haskett wrote on May 8, 2008 6:49 AM:

" The secret is out: Coeur d Alene is recession proof, all the realtors say that there are no real estate problems here and incredibly smokin hot moms come to sit in the pool. "

dbc wrote on May 8, 2008 6:24 AM:

" What pool hall did they drag this joker out of. The majority of jobs here pay at barly poverty levels. "

Next Ad